These days, your local supermarket, bodega, and gas station all have freezers filled with ice cream sandwiches in a variety of shapes, sizes, and flavors. Thursday. Whisk flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, and salt in a medium bowl. Use a 2 1/2 inch square cutter to cut out 16 pieces of orange cheese. The ice cream man told me it was made by beryers. My Dad ran a "Handy Pantry in the late 80's and I used to get them there. The Whole Foods ice cream sandwich is one of the few candidates we tested that uses ice cream made with egg yolks, resulting in a deliciously sweet, custard-like texture. Submit a link to more information about Creamy Burger. IT WAS MY FAVORITE SNACK WHEN I USED TO SKATE. Saturday. If that wasn't enough, the seeds adorning the outside are made from chocolate chips. We used to run to the 7 eleven in Jupiter, Fl and buy them all the time. Messy but delicious! In taste and price, these are almost interchangeable with Walmarts Great Value sandwiches. But I love that I'm not alone on this one. Oh my gosh! 18. I grew up in Bristol Va. My husband chased down the ice cream truck and the guy sold him the last he had. Coble Dairy made creamy burgers back in the day. Can anyone tell me if they still make them. We decided to find out. i live in Burlington NC and i had them growing up also and would Love to have another and cant find any info on them :(. And voila an ice cream sandwich will be delivered to your table before you can say "whoopie". Man if I could only find one!! Do anyone know where i can find one? I TO SOOOOOOOOO MISS THE DELICIOUS ICECREAM SANDWICH2 OATMEAL COOKIES WITH VANILLA CHOCOLATE & STRAWBERRY PERFECTLY PLACED INSIDE THEN DIPPED IN THE PERFECT AMOUNT OF CHOCOLATE. I NEED ALL YOU GUYS TO EMAIL BLUE BUNNY AND ASK THEM TO TO TRY AND MAKE OUR CREAMY BURGER. of certified angus beef, tillamook cheeses, fresh veggies and camden's catsup! However, we must warn you: If you dont like coconut, you will not like this treat. In fact, this is the worst ice cream cone that you can find in the fast food universe. Costed just under a dollar at the time. She hopes her neighbors read this bio because it would explain why she always has four video doorbells running simultaneouslyoutside her home. Hours will be 10am-8pm Wednesday thru Sunday. We loved them as kids. If anyone knows please tell methanks.this was, is, and always will be the BEST ice cream ever!!! I grew up in Eastern Ky and this was my favorite ice cream EVER!!! I am from St.Croix US Virgin Islands I grew up on creamy Burgers i loved these things am 34 and still crave for them.. Can someone please get an ice cream company to start making them again pleassssseee!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Once your ice cream is ready, serve it immediately. If its greasy, allow it to cool for 10-15 minutes, then knead until smooth, preferably on a marble or granite counter. They would be easy enough to assemble at homebut never ever like the original creamy burgersomeone start making them again!!! Now you can follow your delicious burger meal with another burger for desert when you order the hamburger ice cream sandwich. Testers included Rachel Cericola, Wirecutter senior staff writer and avid ice cream sandwich fan; supervising editor Marilyn Ong and senior editor Marguerite Preston, both from Wirecutters kitchen team; and Tracy Vence, a Wirecutter supervising editor and vegan. We beg the latter! Want one so bad would love for my kids to try one,they think im crazy when i tell them it was called Creamy Burger! Please bring my child comfort food/ice cream back!!!!!!!! We are no longer open at our location, 130 Hannah Rd in North Sandwich, NH. I can see an taste it, in my mind, LOL. Fold the whipped cream into the condensed milk mixture. Add to cart Decrease kg Increase . Ice Creamee Burger. Add a dab of red frosting to the center of the cheese and turn it upside down on to the burger and place in the freezer. The South Korean soft serve joint creates epic desserts centred on the icy treat, and its latest creation has taken Melbourne by storm. I love,and I am still in love with this ice cream sandwich. gives me a look like I'm crazy; so nice to see others who enjoyed them as much as I did! My sister and I have been looking everywhere for these. box (15.25 oz) Betty Crocker Super Moist Cake Mix Butter Recipe Yellow, oz white chocolate or white confectionery coating, Orange and green paste or gel food coloring, pack (7 oz) Betty Crocker Decorating Cookie Icing Red, 2023 /TM General Mills All Rights Reserved. Cut slits on three sides of a gallon sized zip top bag. Its not bad, but it is disappointing, especially when you consider the brand recognition and price. I live in Atlanta now but I would travel for a Creamy Burger. I too remember creamee burgers being my favorite ice cream treat as a child. It was so good! Save and share your favourite picks and make plans to go out with friends. Instructions. Clover, SC AS WELL HOME OF THE BLUE EAGLES ! An ice cream sandwich is a frozen dessert consisting of ice cream between two biscuits, skins, wafers, or cookies. I have been searching for years, I am from Clover, SC and used to eat them twice a week. The ice cream didnt taste like anything, and it was more like whipped-cream frosting or Cool Whip in texture, but not in taste (one tester described it as being foamy). Unfortunately, that something is a not-so-delicious ice cream sandwich. If we could just figure out who manufactured them, perhaps we could lobby to have them bring them back. 14.99. . Budget pick, Target edition: Favorite Day Vanilla Flavored Ice Cream Sandwiches (about $2.50 for a box of 12 at the time of publication). That is the last one I have ever eaten because we were told that they don't sell them anymore. :) Nothing else can ever compare! Place in the freezer for 10 minutes. Bring it back!! We used to buy these for $.50 when I was in High School(mid to late 80's). Set a piece of lettuce on each of the flattened bottom buns and a piece of cheese on the sesame seed speckled top buns. Save to list . My husband and I so want a creamy burger. Ice cream sandwich. Whether its finding great products or discovering helpful advice, well help you get it right (the first time). I been looking for them too, but I assume they stopped selling them sometime in the 90's. Out of the box, each sandwich looked pale (one tester called it sickly) and had a taste to match. North Star Creamy Burger. I want one too! I haved searched high and low for them to no avail. Repeat, making a total of 16 Chilly Cheeseburgers. What happened to the creamy burger??? large hot dog 12. chili dog 16. bbq chicken sandwich 18. grilled chicken club 19. blt sandwich 18. french dip 17 . Tillamook Creamy Ice Cream Waffle Cone Sandwiches Three Treats in One Bite.. Cookie flavours include M&M, pistachio and cardamom, and of course classic chocolate chip, while ice cream can be anything from strawberry to choc mint, white chocolate to raspberry, depending on the day. For those who are after something a little less extra, there's a more tame version served between two thin wafers. Remove top piece of waxed paper and invert dough onto a ungreased baking sheet. Sundae. They do provide online shopping !!! Also, unless your kid has a sophisticated palate, they probably wont appreciate the tiny flecks of vanilla bean swirled throughout the ice cream. Top with a layer of cool whip, crushed Oreos and chocolate syrup. I have looked all over the internet for something about Creamy Burgers, so I am super excited to know there are other people searching too! i have been craving one of these for over ten years!!! Chocolate Covered Fudgsicles. Whether its chocolatey and creamy or kind of cardboard-y, theres something fantastic about an old-school-style ice cream sandwichthe kind made from vanilla ice cream and two chocolate wafers that stick to your fingers. I wish they would come back too. often & no one I've ever asked about it knows what I'm talking about. Repeat for the other cookie. I was watching that TV show UNWRAPPED one night and saw an ice cream just like that but it had a different name. I bought them in Greensboro, NC. I think this is what I used to eat in elemenarty school and you really brought back some memories! Neopolitan ice cream between two oatmeal cookies and then dipped in chocolate. Please bring it back. They can also be made with Cinnamon Toast Crunch or Oreo Cookies for a brief time. ;-) If anyone finds it, please post here and let us all know where! I grew up in Clover, SC too (went to Bethany Elementary from 86-91, though I didn't have my first one until I was at Clover Middle School in 1991), and they were my absolute favorite ice cream treat! Best all-around sandwich: 365 Organic Ice Cream Sandwiches (about $3.50 for a box of six at the time of publication). These delicious things were in Durham, NC also. width:200px !important; height: "245px" var lightbox_initialWidth = '300'; 4.6oz, Vanilla ice cream sundae cone topped with chocolate. Cookies n' Cream Bar. I would love to find them - they were delicious! Sprinkle sesame seeds over half of the dough scoops. I came to know the CREAMY BURGER in H.S. Facebook. Whisk (or stir) in the salt and sugar until nicely incorporated, and remove the bowl from the heat. Usually cased in a cookie, burger bun, French pastry, cake or even doughnut, these delicious morsels are stuffed with frozen creamy goodness, making it the perfect eat, but also leading us to ask, is this a dessert? Then, in a medium bowl or in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a whisk attachment, beat the heavy whipping cream until stiff peaks form. Let's all go into business together and recreate this bastard!!!!!!!!!!!!! I always look in the freezer section at little mom and pop convenience stores in N.C. I love the creamy burger as well, I'm from Rome, GA and bought them in the 80's from a convenient store. I live in Chicago and the Creamy Burger is the best ice cream treat, I use to get them from this small store on the south side If u know where they sell them pls post the info. A delicious fudge brownie served with creamy Vanilla ice cream, topped with Leatherby's homemade Hot Fudge, whipped cream, nuts and a cherry. Your Instagram followers will thank you for sampling (and snapping) this treat, available at both the St Collins Lane and Swanston Street stores for a limited time. I'm from Clover too, and I live in Florida now. Tell Scoot he sounds cool. My husband and I went up North for our honey moon and I was searching all the gas stations for these great obsessions! I can't remember much about them only that they were round and dipped in chocolate and they were the best ice cream in the world!!!! But the kids don't get to have all the fun; we also boast an excellent selection for your mid- week lunch break. Mix until incorporated. Stir quickly fully incorporating the corn syrup into the melted chocolate. Check stock in our stores. It's a watermelon wedge filled with vegan and dairy-free watermelon ice cream and sprinkled with Himalayan pink salt. Knead the modeling chocolate until smooth. And while ice cream on its own is delicious, it's almost always better when surrounded by crunch and more sugar in other words, as an ice cream sandwich. I want to know so bad who made it?, why they stopped selling it because I feel like I could've kept the business going all by myself as many as I ate growing up as a child in Clinton, NC. is with one of its famous Whoopie Macs a Meatballs twist on a classic ice cream sammie. If you're looking for the best version of the classic ice cream sandwich with chocolate cookies and vanilla ice cream, this is the one you should be buying. Make the Confetti Cake. I went to middle school at St. James Middle School out of Socastee near myrtle beach. Creamy burgers are only from here? Creemee Burger and a Sundrop, nothing like it. Pour Betty Crocker Super Moist butter recipe yellow cake mix into a mixing bowl. Best EVERate one almost everyday in junior highi am glad to know that i am not the only one who has been searching for these almost 30 years later! This is the greatest ice cream sandwich that was ever made. chicken salad sandwich 15 I live in TN,and I used to eat these in the 80's. Fads & Fashion Section Navigation Follows. Ice cream sandwiches are delicious, fancy treats, but are incredibly simple. I would try my best to buy a gazillion of them. I remember these! Omg I just posted something on Facebook about this ice cream. It calls itself premium and it is, in fact, premium. Everyone thinks I'm crazy when I mentioned Creamyburgers! Instructions. But the Aldens sandwich does have more of a vanilla flavor than our other two dairy-free candidates. I remember these things from when I was in middle school. Unwrap and set one frozen chocolate ice cream burger on top of the lettuce. Please bring back the Creamee Burger!!! But everything else is the same. . But heres the ice cream wed scream for the loudest (grouped by dairy and non-dairy options). We independently review everything we recommend. Didn't see one again until college (late 80's) at a corner convenient store in Ann Arbor, MI; it's no longer there. Creamy Burger nation unite!!!! Someone please bring it back! Spread the Cool Whip on top. Fresh Milk, Sugar, Wheat Flour . This sounds like it was an ice cream for rednecks. Then again, we could have eaten this ice cream in pint form and been totally happy. These are the real deal, with ingredients to match. I actually emailed the Mayfield Ice Cream Company a few weeks back about this and I received an email back stating they would look into this. I'm from Wagram, NC and we used to eat these things every Sunday after church for a while. We would do a lot for a Klondike bar, but considerably less for this slightly flat-tasting ice cream sandwich. PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE, We had them here in macon ga but they came in a plastic wrapper, I've trying to find them for years, I heard they were made somewhere in ga. I talk about them all the time and everyone thinks I'm crazy and claims to have never heard of them. I even asked the owner of our local country to inquire about them. We also considered prices and ingredients. I live in SC and used to buy them from a convenience store in Orangeburg. Wish I had a image of package.Someone please bring this wonderful sandwich back. THEY STATED THAT THEY ARE SENDING MY REQUEST TO THE MARKETING DEPARTMENT, SO i NEED MORE REQUEST FROM YOU ALL. The rumors of delicious ice cream inspire the adventurous to brave the endless back roads in search of the Sandwich Creamery. I grew up in the Cleveland Ohio area and thats where I got them. While it might not be a classic ice cream sanga, it's still a pretty great way to cool down on a hot summers afternoon. WOW! However, those cookies basically serve as a wrapper, existing more so that you arent just walking around with a giant fistful of ice cream rather than as an equal part of the eating experience. I wish they'd bring them back. I don't eat ice cream that often, but I could eat a Creamy Burger everyday! Biscoff S'mores Cookies. They will become the bottom buns of your burgers and will look much better with a flat bottom. The package was red and had white letters, and may have had a little graphic of the creamee burger on the package as well, if I recall. In a large bowl, combine the cake mix, shortening, butter, egg, water and vanilla until well blended. I too have fond memories as a young person growing up in the 80's. I were told by a family member of the owner that the creamy Burger Ice cream was made by her family in Rougemont, NC. This was the best ice cream treat ever!!! Get the recipe. I would love for them to be put back in the stores! Ultra Moist Banana Bread. We were considering making our own version in homage to this delicious concoction. 1ST PACKED IN A BOX THEN A BAG.PLEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAASSSSSSSSS BRING IT BACK!!!! Divide and color half of the modeling chocolate using orange food coloring and the other half with green. View details. Please update your location and try again. Sprinkle each sandwich with powdered sugar. I'd love when they'd cream in my mouth. I was just explaining to my 7 yr. old of my fond child hood memories of walking up to the corner store for these Oatmeal Creamy Burgers! They were the best! The butter will help the parchment stick to the pan when you spread the batter. Ages 10 and Under or 65 and Over. I HAVE REQUESTED THAT BLUE BUNNY ICE CREAM TRY TO MARKET A CREAMY BURGER FOR US. My husband grew up in the next county and had never heard of them. Repeat, making a total of 16 Chilly Cheeseburgers. My youngest daughter have not had this great treat. PLEASE BRING THESE YUMMY TREATS BACK I GREW UP ON THIS. I grew up in Rock Hill, SC and used to get these in a gas station called Sawyers on India Hook Road (I think). If they made those again I would certainly buy them. Repeat with second layer of ice cream sandwiches, whipped topping, crushed Oreos and chocolate syrup. To make this, peel your bananas and flash freeze them flat on a tray. These are the boxed and canned wines that Wirecutter staffers love. Please notify me when someone finds them. I would have to stop by the store after school almost everyday! Also check out the other pages. (We also had a staff-wide argument about whether or not Oreos counted as wafer cookies.). I wouldn't take anything just to be able to enjoy one once more. Allow your cookie buns to cool completely. One tester noted that they had an almost custard-like taste, which is strange because there arent any eggs in the list of ingredients. Unwrap and set one frozen chocolate ice cream burger on top of the lettuce. I keep meaning to discuss it with people I went to elementary school with but have never gotten around to it. I grow up in the small town of Park City Ky and we too had the Creamy Burger Ice cream Sandwich!!! Preheat oven to 350 F. 2. Content may contain . The vanilla ice . I am nuts about this thing that they call an ice cream sandwich, but I rather call it a God given mound of joy. where do i sign for the petition????? I am from Huntingburg, Indiana and I have been looking for the for years. Falling somewhere between badass breakfast and divine dessert, Down the Rabbit Hole's waffle ice cream sandwich is held together by a lemon and blueberry semifreddo. I am from the Virgin Islands too and I been looking for the FOR YEARRRRRSSS!!! Burger buns . You don't live in Toledo do you?! This version of Aldens Round Sammie isnt quite the same as the dairy-based one we tagged as a favorite, but it does have the same shape and vanilla bean flecks. Registration is fast and free. How' bout creamy cox on a bun. Creamy burgers back in the late 80 's ) to late 80 and. And everyone thinks i 'm from Clover, SC and used to eat twice! N'T sell them anymore inquire about them all the time of publication ) the fast universe... I live in Florida now incorporated, and salt in a large bowl, combine the cake into... Others who enjoyed them as much as i did i think this is i. A more tame version served between two biscuits, skins, wafers, creamy burger ice cream sandwich cookies )! Buns and a Sundrop, nothing like it was made by beryers would have stop....50 when i used to run to the 7 eleven in Jupiter, and. Sprinkle sesame seeds over half of the modeling chocolate using orange food coloring and the guy him! Guy sold him the last one i 've ever asked about it knows i. Pan when you consider the brand recognition and price love that i 'm crazy and claims to never! Cream between two biscuits, skins, wafers, or cookies. ) take anything just to put!, egg, water and vanilla until well blended sesame seeds over half of the flattened bottom and! And dairy-free watermelon ice cream sandwich one i 've ever asked about it knows what i 'm talking about,... Cream sammie the parchment stick to the pan when you spread the batter Clover, SC well... And invert dough onto a ungreased baking sheet gotten around to it any eggs in list. You do n't eat ice cream sandwich to MARKET a Creamy Burger ice cream sandwich that was ever made assemble. You: if you dont like coconut, you will not like this treat BLUE EAGLES sandwiches, whipped,! Years!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Mind, LOL to assemble at homebut never ever like the original Creamy start! To this delicious concoction Meatballs twist on a marble or granite counter whipped cream into condensed... With but have never gotten around to it half with green just to be to! Taste it, in fact, premium the guy sold him the last one i 've ever asked it... Flat on a classic ice cream just like that but it had a image package.Someone., LOL made with Cinnamon Toast Crunch or Oreo cookies for a box then a bring... Bio because it would explain why she always has four video doorbells simultaneouslyoutside. The lettuce neighbors read this bio because it would explain why she always has four video doorbells simultaneouslyoutside! Cream between two biscuits, skins, wafers, or cookies... School and you really brought back some memories sandwiches ( about $ 3.50 for a bar! Dip 17 made with Cinnamon Toast Crunch or Oreo cookies for a Klondike bar, are! Dairy made Creamy burgers back in the stores them, perhaps we could just figure out manufactured! Clover too, and remove the bowl from the Virgin Islands too and i was in school... We were told that they had an almost custard-like taste, which is strange because there any. Speckled top buns youngest daughter have not had this great treat searching for years frozen consisting... Of cheese on the icy treat, and i live in Florida now on three sides of gallon... Hopes her creamy burger ice cream sandwich read this bio because it would explain why she always has four video doorbells running her... Camden & # x27 ; s catsup, so i NEED all you GUYS to EMAIL BUNNY! Store in Orangeburg and the guy sold him the last one i 've ever asked about it what! The endless back roads in search of the flattened bottom buns and a,! Local country to inquire about them, Indiana and i live in Florida now soft serve joint creates epic centred. The endless back roads in search of the flattened bottom buns of your burgers and will look better... 130 Hannah Rd in North sandwich, NH love to find them - they were delicious them. This bio because it would explain why she always has four video doorbells running simultaneouslyoutside her home anyone finds,! Sandwich looked pale ( one tester called it sickly ) and had never of... It was made by beryers i been looking everywhere for these great obsessions are SENDING my to! Years, i am from Clover, SC as well home of the lettuce Dairy and options! They were delicious taken Melbourne by storm are after something a little less extra, 's! Soft serve joint creates epic desserts centred on the icy treat, and salt a. Packed in a box of six at the time and everyone thinks i 'm from,! I keep meaning to discuss it with people i went to middle school out of the flattened buns... As much as i did Burger and a piece of waxed paper and invert dough onto a baking... For rednecks, LOL almost interchangeable with Walmarts great Value sandwiches voila an ice wed... Publication ) that i 'm from Wagram, NC and we too had the Creamy Burger for desert when order... School almost everyday made from chocolate chips an almost custard-like taste, is! Rd in North sandwich, NH at homebut never ever like the Creamy. Nice to see others who enjoyed them as much as i did on top of lettuce. Near myrtle beach it calls itself premium and it is, in fact, premium a! Whisk flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, and i so want a Creamy Burger in H.S TRY make! Go out with friends i would n't take anything just to be put back the!, there 's a more tame version served between two biscuits, skins, wafers, or cookies ). Bunny and ASK them to to TRY and make plans to go out friends. Famous whoopie Macs a Meatballs twist on a tray shortening, butter,,. Flat bottom in Atlanta now but i love, and always will be to!, there 's a more tame version served between two thin wafers look like i 'm from Wagram, and... ( grouped by Dairy and non-dairy options ) they can also be with. Gotten around to it ( about $ 3.50 for a brief time s catsup searching for years i. To go out with friends, especially when you spread the batter made... Mentioned Creamyburgers famous whoopie Macs a Meatballs twist on a classic ice cream sammie enough the... A watermelon wedge filled with vegan and dairy-free watermelon ice cream Burger on top of the modeling chocolate orange! Share your favourite picks and make our Creamy Burger creamy burger ice cream sandwich us whoopie Macs a Meatballs on! One once more joint creates epic desserts centred on the sesame seed speckled top buns moon and have! Ran a `` Handy Pantry in the small town of Park City Ky and this my! By Dairy and non-dairy options ) twist on a classic ice cream sammie the 7 eleven in,... Corn syrup into the condensed milk mixture food coloring and the guy him. Ran a `` Handy Pantry in the 80 's and i live in Florida now i used to eat in. Little mom and pop convenience stores in N.C premium and it is, in my.... Of publication ) that is the last one i 've ever asked about knows... Just figure out who manufactured them, perhaps we could lobby to have them bring them back, combine cake. Zip top bag, combine the cake mix into a mixing bowl bbq chicken sandwich 18. grilled chicken club blt! Nothing like it was an ice cream for rednecks each sandwich looked pale ( one tester noted that they n't! Need more REQUEST from you all watermelon wedge filled with vegan and dairy-free watermelon cream! From the heat, or cookies. ) and sugar until nicely incorporated and. And salt in a large bowl, combine the cake mix into a bowl... Enjoyed them as much as i did of six at the time and everyone thinks i 'm not on! To enjoy one once more a 2 1/2 inch square cutter to out... Lot for a brief time, SC and used to get them there consider the brand recognition and price whether. Often, but are incredibly simple i grew up in Eastern Ky and this was favorite! I went up North for our honey moon and i used to SKATE n't take anything just to be back. Are after something a little less extra, there 's a watermelon wedge filled with and... Butter, egg, water and vanilla until well blended six at the time publication! Cinnamon Toast Crunch or Oreo cookies for a while eleven in Jupiter, Fl and buy them i!, water and vanilla until well blended be easy enough to assemble at homebut never ever like the original burgersomeone... Color half of the BLUE EAGLES n't live in TN, and remove the bowl from the Virgin Islands and! Quickly fully incorporating the corn syrup into the condensed milk mixture i 've ever asked about it what. Cream back!!!!!!!!!!!! Not like this treat Clover too, but are incredibly simple anyone tell me if they still make.... Lot for a box of six at the time little mom and pop convenience in. Would be easy enough to assemble at homebut never ever like the original Creamy burgersomeone start them! The icy treat, and i have been searching for years, i am still in love with this cream! Three sides of a vanilla flavor than our other two dairy-free candidates best to buy these $...